Halftime: you are split on this week's leg lesion

Thank you for a lively discussion of Monday's case – in English, French and German. Here is where we stand at halftime, without giving anything away.

The diagnosis poll so far (57 votes, Tuesday night): invasive melanoma 49% · dermatofibroma 37% · spitzoid melanocytic lesion 11% · Clark (dysplastic) nevus 3% · pigmented basal cell carcinoma 0%.

New detail from the comments: the lesion appeared and grew over the past 6 to 12 months.

Three camps in the comments

  • "Melanoma until proven otherwise": blue-white veil, shiny white structures, peppering, pseudopods, peripheral dots and globules, more than three colors, irregular vessels, and a diameter estimated at about 7 mm.

  • "Dermatofibroma": a scar-like white center with a delicate peripheral network, a typical site, age and size. One colleague suggests a hemosiderotic dermatofibroma: more or less symmetric, with a central white network and peripheral hyperpigmentation. But why is it growing?

  • "Nevus with central fibrosis" (dysplastic or spitzoid): fairly regular and centrally organized – only histopathology can decide.

The best questions so far

  • Would an invasive melanoma of this size not show more – an atypical network, irregular dots and globules?

  • What is the blue-white veil on a slightly raised lesion histologically: reactive orthokeratosis, melanophages in the papillary dermis, a dermal infiltrate of atypical melanocytes – or all three?

  • Do the peripheral dots make this lesion melanocytic?

  • Would the dimple sign help you here – and how much would you trust it?

Your turn – two questions before Friday

1. Organized or disorganized – and where do you start in the modified two-step algorithm? Name the one criterion that carries the most weight for you.

2. Management: vote in the poll below and tell us your reasoning in one sentence.

If this lesion walked into your clinic tomorrow: what would you do?

  • Complete excision

  • Partial biopsy (punch or shave)

  • Short-term digital monitoring (3 months)

  • Reassure, no follow-up needed

Haven't voted on the diagnosis yet? Here is the case: Unknown case: a new pink-brown lesion on the leg. Comments in any language are welcome.

The answer follows on Friday at 7:00 a.m. (Zurich time) here in Case of the Week. Evidence Club members then get the complete step-by-step analysis with video, handout and PowerPoint in Case Solutions & Library → Dermoscopy Evidence Club